Just found the fic and chapter1 is exelent. Can't wait to read the others

Excellent story.

::Starts reading the sequel::


#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#
Jack Napier: Have you ever danced with
the devil in the pale moonlight?
- Batman (1989)
#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#=#

Crap. I am now completely hooked on this series, and I blame you entirely.
And now, if you'll excuse me, I have to go read the sequel and find out just who the hell is the mystery person who was pulled through to Middle Earth. You are truely evil. ;)

Great story. Really well done. I greatly enjoyed reading it.

I have been a fan of the Lord of the Rings since I was 7 years old and as one I have always been very weary of crossover stories regarding it. They have always felt forced and I never liked how they would insert characters into major roles (like having Buffy join the Fellowship, etc.), but yours is a story that I can truly say I have enjoyed. It has never felt forced and I like how you have given the Scoobies their own roles to play in this world. It make them much more believable and in my opinion, better characters.

I have read this story a couple of times now and when I first read it I was a little unsure about the whole "The Lord of the Rings is a book where we are from" angle but when you added in events not happening the way they were supposed to until one of the Scoobies nudged things along, it added a whole Quantum Leap style aspect to the story. I grew to like it and it really works well.

Some of my favorite parts were when Buffy, Faith & Spike left with Aragorn to train as rangers, the whole Dawn/Elrohir relationship and Xander being the first one to be offered a ring of power because the bad guys assume he is the weakest of the Scoobies, when he is actually one of the strongest (at least willpower wise).

Great story. :)

Wow - this was a fantstic story! I like how you 'matured' the Buffy cast - differently than they would have had they not been transported and you did it well - enough to show the changes, but you kept enough of what make each person 'unique' to keep it natural.
Really, really great job!
I love the 'soulmates' thing - and Faith's coming into her own is very welcome and very well written.

I look forward to reading the rest of the series!

Awesome. pefectly done. :)

Bravo! Beautifully written! Quite an epic!
I can't wait to read the sequel.
All the Buffyverse characters settled into Middle-Earth about as well as I imagined they would. (Spike's my favorite character, as well!)
How will each of their new destinies in Middle-Earth unfold, I wonder?

Wow, that story was inspired! I have to say that this is the best I've read. The play of emotions and the sequence of events were magnificient. i can't wait to read the sequal;.

I was going to save it and review at the end, but I noticed a tiny mistake in this chapter, so here it is.

First, the good - your story is really quite good. I really like how you've taken the approach that maybe some of the gang /wouldn't/ be happy in ME. So many stories things just turn out so magically well, yours seems more human and true in that respect.

My tiny problem - you have Spike referring to himself as a "bint" in this chapter... that's actually slang for a female... and not really nice slang. Kind of implying she's slutty... So, Spike, being English, would most likely not call himself that.

Sorry to be picky. :-p

*Squeaks*
OMG, that was so good it reduced me to empty-headed acronyms! I love it, hurry on the rest! PLEASE!

*turns into a spluttering Giles* YOu cant-! Oh Gods you can't end it here! C'mon! FIFTY YEARS! Damn you....IT wAS JUST GETTING GOOD TOO! AND THERES SOOOO MANY THINGS TO CONFIRM AND WHATEVER! AND OH GODS YOU HAVE TO MAKE A SEQUAL OR I SWEAR TO GOD I WILL THROW A HARD COPY OF ALL THREE LORD OF THE RINGS BOOKS AND HARRY POTTER BOOKS AS WELL AS THE BUFFY DVD BOX SET AT YOU! *calms down and stop yelling* *glares at you*

I absolutly love your writing. This story is great. I couldn't stop reading. Keep up the awesome work.

hop, i thought they were immortal when you made the comment from arwen in the earlier chapter, not longed lived.. too abd. Hope those seventeen years will see them as much stronger and proficient, and better in mind. Powerful!willow, pretty please? like kickass in hand to hand? ok, going to read your other stories now. tell me if you want me to top reviewing so much, it could be considered s rude...

your nose of sauron is spot on, considering that a "fair man" , or fair creature, or whatever, was sent to the dwarf to make them pledge to sauron.
Good work. Xander was a bit stupid, though.