Be careful What You wish For

Disclaimer: I do not own any of these characters.

Summary: Dawn wants a certain hunter to notice her and borrows a potion from Amy. This is ficlet takes place while Sam is at Stamford, but he never meets Jess or goes on the road with Dean. I aged to put Dawn in Jess is place at Stamford. This was a bad dream I had. Hope you like it It’s a little twisted.

Chapter 1- Love Potion #9

Prologue

Dawn stands leaning on a brick wall with her friends. As a boy passes, she stares and her friends laugh. Dawn Summers, a young woman of 19 at Stamford, California. The young man is Sam Winchester, the captain of the debate team. Dawn has liked him for a long time, but she seems invisible.

Dawn was thinking about political science class and Sam Winchester.” He is so cute, but he doesn’t know I’m alive. Dawn turns and walks down the street, about a block away she sees a shop she's never seen before. It’s called "Whatever You Desire". She goes in and looks around. The shelves are lined with books and glass bottles. Some are romantic novels, other things like How to win your man’s heart in 10 Days. She walks toward the counter where a gypsy woman stands. She looked closer and recognized Amy from Sunnydale.

“Hey! Amy, what are you doing here?” Dawn asked.

“I am selling love and other lucky charms,” Amy replied.

Outside: Whatever You Desire

Dean Winchester watched the young woman walk into the occult shop. I should follow her, he thought. Then his phone rang it was John Winchester Dean and Sam's Father with Dean’s latest assignment. “But dad I want to visit Sam, and besides I think I may have a gig. Well, this girl went into an occult shop to buy a…yeah I know protecting innocents comes before visiting my kid brother or some would be gig. Dean hung up with job looked over his shoulder once more at Dawn and Amy. He got into the Impala and drove in the direction of John’s latest coordinates, seeing Sam would have to wait.

In The Shop

"So, Dawn how can I help you?” Amy asked.

"Oh, no, I'm just looking." Dawn answered quickly. I need something to get his attention, thought Dawn.

Amy smiled as if she could hear Dawn’s thoughts "No one comes here just to look Dawn, what do you need?"

Dawn mumbled, "Nothing that you can help me with I'm sure."

Amy countered "Oh you'd be surprised at what I can do sweetheart. What have you got in mind?"

"Oh this guy, Sam Winchester. He's cute, nice, popular, funny, and he doesn't know I exist."

"I have just what you need." Amy said smiling devilishly.

Amy brought something out from under the counter. It was a pink heart-shaped bottle with a tear drop on it.

"This will help you snag your man Dawn; just three drops and he'll be yours."

"Are you sure Amy? It’s safe right? I don’t want to hurt him; giving him stomach issues, turning him into a rat is not how I want him to notice me." Dawn told her.

"Yes it will work, its an extremely powerful Love Potion. But no more than 3 drops, that's ample amount. No, it will not hurt him or turn him into anything, and he won’t be able to get enough of you."

What could it hurt?thought Dawn. "How much Amy?"

“For you Dawn only $3.00."

"Alright." Dawn grabbed the heart-shaped bottle and headed back to the dorms.

Next Day Lunch

Dawn casually sat next to Sam.

"Uh...Hi Sam." Dawn began shakily.

"You're Dawn right? We have poli- sci together" Sam asked.

Dawn blushes, I can’t believe he knows who I am, thought Dawn. "Yeah, do you want some milk I accidentally bought two cartons?"Dawn asked. Oh my god that sounded lame” she thought. Dawn held out the carton laced with the love potion.

"Yeah, sure." Sam took the carton from her and guzzles it down. He wiped his mouth with his sleeve. "Thanks."

Walking to the Library

“Hey Dawn!" Sam shouted running to catch up with her.

"H..hey Sam." Dawn stuttered.

"Can I walk with you to the library?" Sam asked.

"Yeah sure."

"Here let me take those."Dawn hands him her overdue books.

It's working, he likes me! Dawn thought to herself.

School, Two Weeks Later

Things escalate from there, Sam becomes overbearing, and obsessive and his behavior grows more and more outlandish each passing day. He dedicated all of his debate team wins to Dawn and follows her around like a star struck puppy. Finally, she's had enough. She returns to the shop where she bought the accursed brew."

"Make him stop! He's driving me Crazy!" Dawn told Amy.

With a simpering smile on her face Amy replied, "Sorry Dawn but it's permanent."

“Permanent! I have to have that twit following me around for the rest of my life?" This is bull shit! It was nauseating to think of Sam with her forever.

Amy smirked "Yes, exactly. It’s your fault Dawn. See, He already liked you Dawn, but the potion made him desired beyond control. Now he is all yours forever."

Dawn felt so foolish that she couldn't tell Buffy or Willow about the love potion or trusting Amy. What an idiot I was, she thought. Amy was right, she made her bed and would have to lay in it. She would have to stuck with this love struck Sam and had lost any chance at having anything real with him.

Two years later, Dawn and Sam are married.

Enough is enough! I can't stand him any longer. I need to get out of this. Dawn thought to herself. It came to her as she walked across the road while Sam wasn't looking. He looked up and saw her on the other side. Panic set into him and ran into the road…

"Wait for me!" Sam called out. The traffic light turns green and cars rush towards him. He's hit.

Funeral

Dawn stands over the casket, she is smiling. Everyone is gone. “I’m sorry Sam, but I'm finally rid of you. Good riddance you were driving me crazy. I know that it was my own fault." Dawn motions to leave, but Sam sat up in the casket with a smile on his face.

"Where are you going Dawn?" He asked in tender voice.

"You..You...You're dead. I saw you die. How can this be? What are you? “Dawn asked in hysterics.

"Don't bet on it sweetheart." Sam’s eyes shining a yellow demon like glow.

Dawn screams.